Used fishing gear
Used fishing gear sells through four channels in the US: angler-to-angler marketplaces, general resale sites like eBay and Facebook Marketplace, consignment racks at tackle shops, and secondhand sporting goods stores. The smart play is knowing what to inspect before you pay, whichever channel you buy through. GilledIt is the angler-to-angler option, with payment held in escrow until your gear arrives.
GilledIt is new in the US and listings are still building. Browse what is live in the app and set alerts for the gear you want.
Where to buy used fishing gear
GilledIt marketplace
Angler to angler, photographed and condition graded. Payment sits in Stripe escrow until you confirm the gear arrived as described. Browse on the website, buy in the app.
SidelineSwap and eBay
The widest selection, with buyer protection that works but resolves slowly. Prices run higher because sellers price in the fees. Check feedback on fishing gear specifically, not just overall.
Facebook Marketplace and Craigslist
The cheapest prices and good for local deals, but no buyer protection. Meet in daylight, test the gear in hand, and never pay by friends-and-family transfer.
Tackle shop consignment and Play It Again Sports
Inspect before you buy, which removes most of the risk. Selection is limited to local walk-ins, and shop margin means higher prices than a private sale.
What to check before you buy, item by item
Rods: sight down the blank for straightness and hairline cracks. Check guides for braid grooves and cracked inserts, ferrule fit for twist, and the reel seat for smooth threads. Bass and saltwater rods lead hard lives, so ask how it was stored.
Reels: spin the handle and listen for grinding, test the drag from light to locked, check the bail snaps shut crisply, and inspect the spool lip for dings. Saltwater history matters most: corrosion hides inside the body long before it shows outside.
Electronics: fish finders and trolling motors need a powered test before money changes hands. Check battery terminals and connectors for corrosion and confirm the transducer is included and undamaged.
Ice gear: check shelter poles and zips, auger blades for chips, and heater ignitions. Off-season is when the bargains appear.
Line: always buy new. Mono and fluoro degrade with UV and time no matter how the spool looks.
Used fishing gear near me
GilledIt listings are nationwide with the distance to every seller shown in the app, so the closest deals surface first. Sellers choose tracked shipping or local pickup. If you pick up locally, pay through the app anyway so the escrow protection still applies.
How buying on GilledIt protects you
Your payment goes into Stripe-managed escrow, not to the seller. Funds release when you confirm the gear arrived as described or tracking confirms delivery. If something is wrong, open a dispute and we mediate with the money still held.
Used fishing gear: FAQ
For buyer protection, an angler-to-angler marketplace like GilledIt is safest because payment is held in escrow until the gear arrives. SidelineSwap and eBay offer wide selection with slower dispute processes. Facebook Marketplace and Craigslist are cheapest but carry the most scam risk. Tackle shops with consignment sections let you inspect before buying.
Sight down the blank for straightness and hairline cracks, check every guide for grooves and cracked inserts, make sure ferrules seat snugly without twist, and check the reel seat threads run smooth. For used reels, test the drag from light to locked, listen for gear grinding, and ask whether it has seen saltwater.
GilledIt listings come from anglers nationwide, and the app shows the distance to each seller, so you can choose local pickup or tracked shipping. Play It Again Sports, pawn shops, and tackle shop consignment racks are the in-person alternatives.
Usually, yes. Quality rods and reels are built to last decades and used prices sit well below retail. Buy fishing line new, though: it degrades with age and sunlight regardless of how the spool looks, and old line costs fish.
Selling instead? Who buys used fishing gear and what it is worth · Used fly fishing gear guide